Week 4

Product: Teat and cover of a polycarbonate baby milk bottle

 

Teat of a polycarbonate baby milk bottle

Function

Allows the baby to suck milk out of the milk bottle.

Constraints

High Young’s Modulus, High corrosion-resistance, Non-reactive, High Tensile Strength, High Melting Point, Availability

Objectives

Excellent corrosion-resistance & non-reactive

Material

Rubber, Silicone Rubber, Ethylene Propylene Diene Monomer

 

Cover of polycarbonate baby milk bottle

Function

Prevent dust particles and impurities from entering the teat.

Constraints

High Tensile Strength, Availability, Low Density, High corrosion-resistance, non-reactive.

Objectives

Relatively high tensile strength

Materials

Plastic, Borosilicate Glass, Stainless Steel, Gold


 Select and Evaluate Candidate Materials

Criteria Selection for teat:

The 6 selected criteria for teat are Young’s Modulus, Corrosion Resistance, Melting Point, Chemical Reactivity, Ultimate Tensile Strength, and Availability.

The corrosion resistant and chemical reactivity have the highest weightage of 30%. This is because the material for the teat is in contact with the milk, water and washing detergent. It should be non-reactive and must not form toxic product. The material used for teat should also have high corrosion resistance as it contacts with water frequently. 

The ultimate tensile strength has the second highest weightage of 15%. A high tensile strength means that the material is more durable and has a higher resistance to breaking under tension. The teat must have high tensile strength. This allows the teat to be able to withstand force applied by the baby’s teeth and the cover to not break easily when dropped.

Both young’s modulus and melting point has the same weightage of 10%. Young’s modulus is needed to check if the teat is soft and elastic. When the teat is elastic and soft, this will not hurt the baby’s teeth when bit on it and the teat will not deform.  It also gives a more real feeling of a mother’s nipple. Melting point is also used for teat, but it has a low weightage of 10% because the milk will usually be warm, which is below 100°C. Most materials would have a melting point of above 100°C. Thus, melting point is given a low weightage.

Lastly, the availability of material is given as 5%. As the baby bottle teat will be placed into the baby’s mouth, this product plays an important role which prevents the baby from getting sick. The health of the baby is much more important. Thus, we cannot substitute a material which is easier to find but has a poorer quality with a material which is harder to find but has much better qualities which can help protect the baby’s health.


Criteria selection for cover:

The 5 selected criteria for the cover are Ultimate Tensile Strength, Density, Availability, Corrosion Resistance and Chemical Reactivity.

The ultimate tensile strength has the highest weightage of 30%. A high tensile strength means that the material is more durable and has a higher resistance to breaking under tension. The cover must have high tensile strength. This allows the cover to be able to withstand dropping easily so that it will not break.

Similarly for density, it also has a weightage of 30%. The density of the material can tell us the weight of the material. As the baby does not possess much strength yet, the total weight of the bottle has to be light so that it can carry itself to drink when the baby gets old enough. Therefore, density plays a big part when choosing the desired material.

Corrosion resistance has a weightage of 20%. This is because the material for the cover is in contact with the milk if there is spillage and will also be in contact with water and washing detergent when the baby bottle is needed to be washed. Therefore, the material should be non-reactive and must not form toxic product. The material used for cover should have high corrosion resistance as it contacts with water frequently. 

Chemical reactivity has a weightage of 10%. As the cover would be in contact with water more often, corrosion resistance has a higher weightage. However, the chemical resistance is still important as milk may be spilled onto the cover. The material for the cover still has to be non-reactive and must not form toxic product.

Lastly, the availability of material is given as 10%. As the baby bottle cover is used to prevent dust or impurities from entering the teat, this product plays an important role which prevents the baby from getting sick. The health of the baby is much more important. Thus, we cannot substitute a material which is easier to find but has a poorer quality with a material which is harder to find but has much better qualities which can help protect the baby’s health.


TEAT

Options

Criteria

Weightage

Nitrile Rubber

Silicone Rubber

Latex

 

 

 

Score

Value

Score

Value

Score

Value

Young’s Modulus (MPA)

10%

1

3

3

950

2

100

Corrosion Resistance

30%

3

A

2

B

3

A

Melting Point (°C)

10%

1

120

3

1414

1

120

Chemical Reactivity

(Fatty Acids and Lactic Acid)

 

 

30%

 

 

1

 

 

C, D

 

 

2

 

 

C, A

 

 

2

 

 

C, A

Ultimate Tensile Strength (MPA)

 

15%

 

1

 

15.2

 

3

 

82.6

 

2

 

17.5

Availability

5%

3

-

2

-

2

-

Total

100%

170

235

220

 

COVER

Options

Criteria

Weightage

Polyethersulfone

Borosilicate-Glass

 

316 Stainless Steel

Gold

 

 

 

Score

Value

Score

Value

Score

Value

Score

Value

Ultimate Tensile Strength (MPa)

30%

2

143.25

1

81.6

3

586

2

120

Density (g/cc)

30%

 

3

1.53

3

2.4

2

7.95

1

19.2

 

Availability

 

 

10%

 

 

3

 

-

 

3

 

-

 

3

 

-

 

 

1

 

-

Corrosion Resistance

20%

 

 

3

A

3

A

3

A

3

A

Chemical Reactivity

(Fatty Acids and Lactic Acid)

 

 

10%

 

 

 

3

 

 

A, B

 

 

3

 

 

A, B

 

 

3

 

 

A, B

 

 

3

 

 

A, B

Total

100%

270

240

270

190


The best 2 materials for teat are Silicone-Rubber and Latex.

The best 2 materials for cover are Polyethersulfone and 316 Stainless Steel.

 

Select and Evaluate most economical material

Criteria Selection:

The 3 selected criteria are Cost, Density, Machineability. The cost has a high weightage of 50%, density and machineability has a weightage of 25% each.

Cost has the highest weightage as it must be cheap so that it can be mass produced and make maximum profit.

Density and machineability has the same weightage as they are equally important. Density in this case tells us the transportation cost. A material with higher density will cost more for transportation. Machinability refers to how easy a material can be shape and machine into what we need. Thus, both density and machineability has the same weightage of 25%.

 

 

TEAT

Options

Criteria

Weightage

Silicone-Rubber

Latex

 

 

Score

Value

Score

Value

Density (g/cc)

25%

2

2.25

3

0.92

Cost ($/lb)

50%

2

25.00

3

1.08

Machineability

25%

2

-

3

-

Total Score

100%

200

300

 

 

COVER

Options

Criteria

Weightage

Polyethersulfone (PES)

316 Stainless Steel

 

 

Score

Value

Score

Value

Density (g/cc)

25%

3

1.53

1

7.95

Cost ($/lb)

50%

2

14.00

3

0.84

Machineability

25%

3

-

1

-

Total Score

100%

250

200

 

In conclusion, latex is use as material for the teat, and polyethersulfone (PES) is used as the material for the cover.

 

Latex has high young’s modulus which means that it is elastic. This allows it to withstand biting and pulling from the baby, which can also prevent the baby from hurting its teeth as it is soft. It also has a high corrosion resistance, which means that it will not corrode when water is introduced. This makes washing the teat possible with water. Latex is also relatively inert so washing detergent and milk will not chemically affect it. Although it has a C grade towards fatty acids, fatty acids composition is very little inside milk, thus it will not affect much. It also has a decently high melting point, at 120°C, which makes it suitable to be used as warm milk will be flowing through it. The warm milk will not exceed 120°C thus latex low melting point is acceptable. Latex also has a high ultimate tensile strength which increases its resistance to wear and tear, making it more durable. Latex is a readily available material which makes it cheap and easy to obtain. Besides being cheap, latex is also very light as it has low density which makes it suitable for a baby to use as baby's do not have much strength. A low density also means that the transportation cost will be lower, therefore, companies get to save more on expenses. Machinability rating for latex is also very high which is also very important as teats comes in all shapes and sizes and hence needs to be easily moulded into whatever form is needed. Therefore, latex is chosen as the material for the teat.

 

 

PES has a decently high ultimate tensile strength which increases its overall durability and resistance to wear and tear and dropping. It is also a commonly used material for baby feeding bottles which makes it readily available. In addition, PES is light, making it a good choice for baby’s who lack strength. A high corrosion resistant means that washing the cover will not form toxic product. The chemicals commonly found in milk (fatty acids and lactic acids) also do not react with PES to form toxic product. Besides these functional properties, PES is also a great option from an economic standpoint as it is light and strong, reducing transport cost, it is a cheap material in general and is very easy to machine i.e. it is very mouldable. Therefore, PES is chosen as the material for the cover. Moreover, baby feeding bottles are made using PES plastic, which does not contain BPA. BPA is a compound which some researches claim is detrimental to human health.



References

-          Coleparmer.com. n.d. Chemical Compatibility Database from Cole-Parmer. [online] Available at: <https://www.coleparmer.com/chemical-resistance> [Accessed 11 May 2021].

 

-         latex, E., n.d. Elasticity of latex. [online] Chemistry Stack Exchange. Available at: <https://chemistry.stackexchange.com/questions/20008/elasticity-of-latex#:~:text=In%20'engineering%20materials%20terms'%20the,modulus%20of%20about%200.1%20GPa.> [Accessed 12 May 2021].

 

-          Matweb.com. 2021. Online Materials Information Resource - MatWeb. [online] Available at: <http://www.matweb.com/> [Accessed 11 May 2021].

 

-          Mykin.com. 2021. Rubber Chemical Resistance, Rubber Chemical Compatibility, Page 3 - Mykin Inc. [online] Available at: <https://mykin.com/rubber-chemical-resistance-chart-3> [Accessed 11 May 2021].

 

-          n.d. [ebook] Available at: <https://www.flinnsci.com/api/library/Download/8c21e94f13bb429c90501abbe58400c5#:~:text=Rubber%20latex%20begins%20to%20melt%20and%20decompose%20at%20approximately%20120%20%C2%B0C.> [Accessed 12 May 2021].

 

-         Techiescientist. n.d. Does Silicone Melt? - Techiescientist. [online] Available at: <https://techiescientist.com/does-silicone-melt/#:~:text=about%20the%20silicone.-,Does%20silicone%20melt%3F,hardly%20looses%20its%20physical%20properties.> [Accessed 12 May 2021].







Learning Points:

COWS Matrix is used for material selection which aims to seek the best match between design requirement of a product or process and material attributes. The COWS matrix stands for Criteria, Options, Weightage and Score. Before using COWS matrix, we have to define the product function, define the product requirements, translate product requirements into material properties, identify probable candidates materials and then we can use COWS matrix to select most suitable material(s). 

COWS matrix helps to score the identified probable materials using the relevant criteria. We can obtain the data for each criteria for each material candidate using websites such as "matweb and "coleparmer". Matweb gives us the individual material properties and coleparmer can give us the material compatibility.

COWS matrix is feasible as it is easy to use and allows us to easily identify the best material for the given criteria and purpose. 

COWS matrix allows the user to contextualize certain criteria for certain usage. For example, to put into context, the user needs a material that can withstand high pressure and temperature. The user can use COWS matrix with the criteria of able to withstand high pressure and temperature to get the best material.


Basis of scoring: To score the probable materials, we give them a score of "1" to "3", with "3" being the best and "1" being the worst. After scoring all the materials based on the criteria, we can add up their total score. The material with the highest scoring is selected to be the best material for the given product.


2) Group Assignment
For the group assignment, our group was given the product of a teat and cover of a polycarbonate baby milk bottle. Firstly, we had to define each product function, and the product requirements. Next, we then translated the product requirements into material properties. An example is given below: 

Teat of a polycarbonate baby milk bottle

Function

Allows the baby to suck milk out of the milk bottle.

Constraints

High Young’s Modulus, High corrosion-resistance, Non-reactive, High Tensile Strength, High Melting Point, Availability

Objectives

Excellent corrosion-resistance & non-reactive

Material

Rubber, Silicone Rubber, Ethylene Propylene Diene Monomer


After listing out the functions, constraints, objectives and the probable materials, we can then use COWS matrix to identify the best material to be used. We had to score the materials candidates using data we found online. After getting all the data, we summed up their individual scores and the material with the highest score is selected as the best material for the product. 



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Week 5

Design for Materials (DFM) Design for materials is the opposite of MFD. Instead of choosing the best material for the product, DFM is changing a design so that a particular material can be used. DFM can be used when the material used is expensive and we want to make sure we do not waste it. We can then use DFM to create a design which can make full use of the material, so that we will not waste any of it. Another example when DFM is used is when the material is not commonly used. We can then used DFM to make a product using the material. We can then cut down the used of commonly use materials with another material which is not commonly used. For our assignment, we had come up with a material and use it to enhance the functionality of an existing product through some changed in the design. We had chose the material "Alcantara" which is mostly used for making car seats' cover. We had thought to use Alcantara to make phone covers, or any product which requires a good grip. T...
Read more

Week 1

Image
Chemical Product - One word from the broad category:  Household - One word from the sub-category:  Appliance - Chemical product:  Refrigerator - Chemical engineering principles:  Vapor-Compression cycle, Heat transfer - Category:  Chemical Device   ( Although it is not considered as a miniature device, refrigerator does not fit in any of the other categories; commodities, molecular products or micro-structured product) The chosen product is a refrigerator. The refrigerant evaporates completely to absorb the heat from the surrounding region to be refrigerated. The refrigerant will leave the evaporator and then enters the compressor to increase its pressure so that it can reach the condenser. The gaseous refrigerant is then cooled back into a liquid state where the heat is released into the surrounding. The refrigerant is ready to absorb heat through the evaporator again.  Vapor-Compression cycle: More details of how the cycle works: The ...
Read more

Week 2

Image
  Plastic To Fuel (Using Pyrolysis) Why is this a good idea? Plastics are inexpensive and durable. As a result, level of plastic production by humans are high. Moreover, the chemical structure of most plastics renders them to resistant to many natural processes of degradation. As a result, plastics are slow to degrade. These 2 factors combined to have led to a high prominence of plastic pollution in the environment. Another factor is also humans, are not having the habit to recycle plastics, or even just throwing out our trash into bins. As a result, millions of animals are killed by plastics every year. However, there are many ways we can reduce plastic pollution by converting these waste plastics into useful resources. One of the ways is to reuse plastics and convert them into fuels. Brief Explanation of how it works Plastic has to go through a densifier that compresses the plastic pieces into dense material to facilitate easier storage . The pyrolysis process takes place in a ch...
Read more